The Paradox of Consensualism in International Law

The Paradox of Consensualism in International Law
Author :
Publisher : BRILL
Total Pages : 344
Release :
ISBN-10 : 9789004635234
ISBN-13 : 9004635238
Rating : 4/5 (238 Downloads)

Book Synopsis The Paradox of Consensualism in International Law by : C.L. Lim

Download or read book The Paradox of Consensualism in International Law written by C.L. Lim and published by BRILL. This book was released on 2024-01-15 with total page 344 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: If international law is derived from the consent of States, who should be in a better position to say what has been consented to than the disputing States themselves? It seems that if the doctrine of consent is taken seriously, there would be no room for an 'objective' legal answer to the question `What is law?'. Furthermore, States do not necessarily employ the same criteria for determining the applicable law when engaged in dispute. And the doctrine of sovereignty is of very limited utility, since not all of substantive international law can be explained in terms of the atomic concept of sovereignty. This leaves consent as the mediating concept between the substantive doctrine of international law on the one hand and the actual practice of States (and others whose practice and participation in the global legal order help shape the body of international laws) on the other. Nevertheless, this is not to say that there is nothing `higher' than the actual legal claims forwarded by international actors. International law is no mere superstition, since none argue that there is no (one) legal solution. In that sense, the unity of the international legal order is preserved. The problem is that the solutions actually forwarded in dispute are too numerous and international law too abstract to serve as arbiters between the competing claims. Thus, at the level of substantive doctrine there is a fragmentation of that earlier-mentioned picture of unity. But even here, only consent can mediate between unity and fragmentation, stability and change, order and justice, legislation and revolution. The strength of international law lies in its adaptability to political, strategic and diplomatic necessities. To suggest otherwise is to depart from a picture of international law that presumes the empirical verifiability of international laws. This book has as its principal concern certain orthodoxies of `source thinking' in international law, and is aimed at working out the implications of these. It aims to show how certain theoretical conceptions have shaped the law in action, for good or ill. It will appeal to political theorists, diplomats, global decision-makers, and international lawyers who are interested in the question `What can we do with the international law that we have?', as distinct from the question `What should we do with international law?'.


The Paradox of Consensualism in International Law Related Books

The Paradox of Consensualism in International Law
Language: en
Pages: 344
Authors: C.L. Lim
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2024-01-15 - Publisher: BRILL

GET EBOOK

If international law is derived from the consent of States, who should be in a better position to say what has been consented to than the disputing States thems
The Paradox of Consensualism in International Law
Language: en
Pages: 322
Authors: O. A. Elias
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 1998-01-01 - Publisher: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers

GET EBOOK

If international law is derived from the consent of States, who should be in a better position to say what has been consented to than the disputing States thems
The Persistent Objector Rule in International Law
Language: en
Pages: 353
Authors: James A. Green
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2016-03-03 - Publisher: Oxford University Press

GET EBOOK

The persistent objector rule is said to provide states with an 'escape hatch' from the otherwise universal binding force of customary international law. It prov
The Institutional Problem in Modern International Law
Language: en
Pages: 468
Authors: Richard Collins
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2016-11-03 - Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing

GET EBOOK

Modern international law is widely understood as an autonomous system of binding legal rules. Nevertheless, this claim to autonomy is far from uncontroversial.
Consenting to International Law
Language: en
Pages: 393
Authors: Samantha Besson
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2023-11-30 - Publisher: Cambridge University Press

GET EBOOK

The obligations stemming from international law are still predominantly considered, despite important normative and descriptive critiques, as being 'based' on (